I think we’re only just beginning to recognise the useful ways in which technology can be combined with public transport to both make the trip nicer and to also analyse the PT system and work out ways in which to improve it. Much of this work is going on outside official agencies – which seem stuck in the dark age when it comes to such matters (try using the MAXX journey planner on a mobile phone, a painful process!)
Back in January we saw Auckland’s entire PT network simulated over the course of a day, in this fantastic video put together by Sciblogs.
An animated map of Auckland’s public transport network from Chris McDowall on Vimeo.
Now there’s a new piece of software, known as “Mapnificent“, that provides an incredibly useful resource: the extent of a city that’s accessible within a certain timeframe via public transport at various different hours of the day. This video explains how it works:
Mapnificent from Stefan Wehrmeyer on Vimeo.
Some of the functions are incredibly useful, I suspect particularly for those searching for houses or working out whether a particular job will be accessible for them via public transport in a feasible way or not. It would be interesting to see, over time, whether real estate agents reckon this is a helpful tool in trying to sell places – it’ll be particularly obvious the parts of the city within say a half-hour PT commute from downtown. If you worked across the road from Britomart train station, and accepted up to a 15 minute walk, you can see in the image below how much of the city would be within 30 minutes of travel time: It’s a surprisingly small portion of the city really, although I guess that’s because of walking times to and from the bus stop or train station. Interesting how effective the Northern Busway is at creating points on the North Shore that are dramatically more accessible than what’s around them. It’s crazy that most of the catchment of Akoranga Station is a golf driving range, and most of Smales Farm’s catchment is a golf course and a massive parking building. If there were ever parts of the city appropriate and attractive for intensification, these are those point. The fantastic speed of trains on the Eastern Line, and I assume the good speed of buses along Remuera Road and Tamaki Drive give that part of the city a surprisingly good score.
Push the time limit out to 60 minutes, and we start to see which parts of the city have particularly bad public transport – in that they can’t even get a peak time trip to Britomart in less than an hour: If you ever wanted a visual representation of why it’s stupid to have focused so much of Auckland’s urban development in Flat Bush, Botany Downs, Dannemora and so forth – then this is that proof. Heck even Beachlands and parts of Waiheke Island are more accessible to the CBD than a vast swathe of southeast Auckland. But there are interesting holes too – Te Atatu Peninsula and Massey are suprisingly excluded, a good argument for the Northwest Busway perhaps?
But Britomart is a really accessible point of downtown. How about if we shifted the focus point to somewhere outside easy walking distance of the current rail network – like the Auckland Town Hall. What impact does that have on what’s accessible in an hour long PT trip or less: Accessibility from the south and west is reduced quite significantly, while that southeast area is now well outside the 60 minute accessibility area (indicating that it would probably take people a lot longer than an hour to get to the town hall from these places. One big advantage of the City Rail Link project is that it will bring much more of the city within a reasonable commute of all the CBD, not just the area around Britomart.
However, if we think public transport to the CBD is bad, remember that only 13% of Auckland’s jobs are in the CBD. Other large employment hubs include around Greenlane/Ellerslie, in East Tamaki, Albany and at the Airport. The 60 minute accessibility zones for these are are pretty terrible (and remember that this is for an hour each way, probably the very limit of acceptability):
I wonder if such maps might make our planner reconsider the merits of decentralising employment. I would also think twice about shifting to Flat Bush any time soon – remembering that the map shows areas within a one hour commute:
The potential uses for this tool are endless. What a fantastic resource!
Very cool
Wonderful. Although now I have graphic proof that you can’t get from Grey Lynn to Mt Eden in half an hour, which is shocking and reinforces my call for regular Bond St buses.
What would be particularly awesome is the ability to use this to show the impact of proposed projects.
moving the slider and seeing how the RTN stations jump out of the darkness is really great, same effect in Wellington.
Interesting also seeing how different parts of the CBD are so much easier/difficult to reach from different areas.
Also really highlights the need for vastly improved cross-town services for jobgs in Ellerslie/Greenlne/Penrose/Otahuhu
The 30min zones stretch far south and north to the CBD and Takanini, but dont make it to Mount Roskill, Mt Eden, Mt Albert, Sandringham, Lynfield etc.
Brilliant, the very piece of software I’ve been imagining in my head! I like how Constellation has its own little circle on that top map, makes me even more thankful that I live right by it :).
Very cool!
Some of the time estimates for shorter distances don’t look very realistic. I’m guessing that they don’t include waiting time. 14 minutes from Takapuna to half way up Queen St doesn’t feel like enough.
I needed to zoom up to 125 minutes before I got a CBD destination to reach out to Len Brown’s home. If he wants to promote a public transport based city rather than a car based sprawl then he REALLY needs to move closer to the office.
Obi,
In the settings you can select the time of day and day of the week for the software.
Found that. What do the Night and OSM buttons do, apart from change the look of the map?
It says rush hour airport to city should take 100 minutes. The airport bus web site says it is nominally 45 minutes, but expect an extra 10 minutes at rush hour. Maybe it doesn’t have the airport shuttles included as public transport?
I’m enjoying playing with this. Cleverest thing I’ve seen in a while.
Id be surprised if the airport shuttles were included. They dont operate on a regular schedule. You have to request them.
http://www.airbus.co.nz/ leave every 15 minutes during the day.
@LTI – the airbus isn’t one of those shuttle buses you’re thinking of, it’s a scheduled bus that runs 24hrs a day and at times every 15mins between downtown and the airport.
It is rather shocking that it takes 70 minutes to get from Swanson to Westharbour by public tranport, while using only the rail network would get you all the way into Newmarket and out to Penrose in that time.
Great to see the travelling times are realistic. My commute is about 95 minutes each way, Waiheke-Grey Lynn, due to the interminable waits when switching transport modes bus-ferry-bus, and the map confirms it.
Something VERY interesting is to compare the PT efficiency of Auckland and Wellington by checking what kind of area is covered for major business/recreation destinations. As far as I can tell, they’re just about equal, shockingly enough.
That last map is shocking considering that all of the development (half a million additional people expected to be living there by 2025 or something IIRC). I live in Bucklands Beach (on the peninsula) and I know damn well I could cycle to Flatbush (should I ever feel the need) AND back home in less than 60 minutes. My wife used to cycle to East Tamaki from home in about 30 minutes to work and reckoned it was miles quicker than PT. I see now that she was almost certainly right. And just to clarify, neither of us are hardcore cyclists, just a normal level of ‘fit’. I do believe that the maps are a little off though, for example, the ferry trip to Half Moon bay is half an hour so that should fit on the first map.
That last map is shocking considering that all of the development (half a million additional people expected to be living there by 2025 or something IIRC). I live in Bucklands Beach (on the peninsula) and I know damn well I could cycle to Flatbush (should I ever feel the need) AND back home in less than 60 minutes. My wife used to cycle to East Tamaki from home in about 30 minutes to work and reckoned it was miles quicker than PT. I see now that she was almost certainly right. And just to clarify, neither of us are hardcore cyclists, just a normal level of ‘fit’. I do believe that the maps are a little off though, for example, the ferry trip to Half Moon bay from the ferry building is half an hour so that should fit on the first map.
I personally find that its not completely accurate – for instance I could be at work at my old workplace in under 20mins (Newmarket – Viaduct Harbour), whereas now it takes me about 30mins (usually walk as most of the time its faster than the link) to get from Newmarket to just past the K Rd overbridge.
However I’d say for longer distances its pretty close.
interesting to see that new North Road buses are significantly faster than either B-Line service, and also that Mt Eden Road buses are faster than Dominion Road buses up to Balmoral Road, after which those on Mt Eden road slow to a crawl.
This piece of software is great – looking forward to seeing its potential unleashed!
As mentioned above, waiting time is important. The map would be even better if it took into account frequency – by , say, adding half the interval to the journey time. Suddenly places with a 10 minute frequency would look so much more accessible than those with hourly. It would incidentally highlight where a bike wins out, with its 0 interval – it is always there when you want – played against its slightly longer journey time.
This is awesome.
Yes, it doesn’t show waiting time but I’m not sure it should – I can delay when I leave work to avoid much of that anyway. I did notice some timings were inaccurate and it’s missing some routes (e.g. Wellington trains seem to be missing) but it’s still very, very useful.